Mortgage Comparison Calculator

The 15-Year vs 30-Year Mortgage Decision

The choice between 15-year and 30-year mortgages is one of the most consequential financial decisions you'll make, with hundreds of thousands of dollars at stake. Consider a $300,000 loan: at 5.5% for 30 years, your monthly payment is $1,703 and you'll pay $313,000 in total interest. The same amount at 5% for 15 years costs $2,372 monthly but only $127,000 in total interest—a savings of $186,000. That's life-changing money that could fund retirement, college, or other goals. However, the 15-year mortgage requires $669 more monthly, which many households struggle to afford comfortably. The financial conventional wisdom says to take the 30-year mortgage if you'll invest the payment difference; if you reliably invested that $669 monthly at 8% returns for 15 years, you'd accumulate about $245,000—more than the interest savings. But here's the reality: most people don't actually invest the difference; it gets absorbed into lifestyle spending. The 15-year mortgage essentially forces a savings discipline. There's also a psychological factor—being mortgage-free in 15 years rather than 30 provides tremendous financial flexibility and peace of mind during your peak earning years. A middle-ground strategy is taking the 30-year mortgage for payment flexibility but making extra payments as if it were a 15-year loan; this gives you the option to pull back if circumstances change, unlike the 15-year mortgage's higher required payment.

Understanding How Points and Fees Affect Your Decision

Comparing mortgages requires looking beyond the interest rate to understand the true cost of borrowing. Lenders often offer rate buy-downs through discount points—prepaid interest that reduces your rate. One point typically costs 1% of the loan amount and reduces your rate by about 0.25%. On a $300,000 loan, paying two points ($6,000) to reduce your rate from 6.5% to 6% lowers your monthly payment from $1,896 to $1,799—saving $97 monthly or $34,920 over 30 years. The points pay for themselves in 62 months (about 5 years), so if you'll stay in the home longer, they're worthwhile. However, if you might move or refinance within 5 years, you'll lose money on the points. Closing costs also vary between lenders; one might quote 6% with $2,000 closing costs while another offers 5.75% with $5,000 closing costs. To compare, calculate the break-even point: the $3,000 higher closing cost is offset by saving $47 monthly, so you break even in 64 months. No-closing-cost mortgages are another option, where the lender pays closing costs but charges a higher rate—typically 0.25-0.5% higher. This works well if you might refinance soon or have limited cash for closing. The key is comparing the all-in cost over your expected holding period, not just the rate or payment in isolation. Create a spreadsheet comparing total costs (closing costs plus all payments) over 5, 10, and 15-year periods to see which loan truly costs less based on realistic timelines.

Comparing Fixed-Rate and Adjustable-Rate Mortgages

Adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs) offer a lower initial interest rate than fixed-rate mortgages but carry uncertainty and risk. A common structure is the 5/1 ARM: the rate is fixed for five years, then adjusts annually based on an index plus a margin. You might get a 5% rate on a 5/1 ARM when 30-year fixed rates are 6.5%—a substantial initial savings. On a $300,000 loan, this means $1,610 monthly instead of $1,896, saving $286 monthly or $17,160 over five years. The gamble is what happens at year six when the rate adjusts. If rates have risen to 8%, your payment could jump to $2,174—a $564 increase from the original payment. ARMs have caps limiting how much the rate can increase per adjustment and over the loan's life, typically 2% per adjustment and 5% lifetime, but even these caps can produce payment shock. ARMs make sense in specific scenarios: if you'll definitely move or refinance within the fixed period (like military families with frequent relocations), if you expect income to rise substantially (young professionals early in high-earning careers), or if you believe rates will fall and want to benefit from the decrease. They're risky if you need payment certainty for budgeting, are stretching to afford the home, or plan to stay long-term. Many borrowers who took ARMs in the early 2000s faced foreclosure when rates reset higher during the 2008 financial crisis, highlighting the danger of counting on refinancing—when home values drop or credit tightens, refinancing might not be available when you need it.